Alright, let’s dive into a topic that can cause a lot of confusion in relationships—personal boundaries versus being controlling. If you’re like most people, you want healthy relationships with your spouse, kids, friends, and co-workers. But in trying to create those healthy connections, it’s easy to cross the line between setting good boundaries and becoming a controlling nightmare.
So what’s the difference? How do you know if you’re setting a boundary to protect your heart, your time, or your energy—or if you’re just trying to control someone else’s life?
First, What Are Boundaries?
A boundary is about you. It’s a line you draw around yourself to protect your mental, emotional, and physical well-being. It’s like saying, “Here’s where I stop and you start.” Boundaries are healthy, necessary, and a fundamental part of taking care of yourself.
For example, let’s say your friend constantly shows up late to hangouts, and it drives you nuts. A boundary might be telling them, “If you’re more than 15 minutes late, I’m going to leave and do something else.” It’s not about forcing them to be on time; it’s about what you will do to manage your time and frustration.
Or maybe you’ve got a relative who loves talking about politics, but it stresses you out. A boundary could be saying, “I’m not comfortable discussing politics. If the conversation goes there, I’ll excuse myself.”
Setting boundaries is not about controlling someone else’s behavior. It’s about you deciding what you will or will not tolerate. It’s taking responsibility for your actions and your choices, not theirs.
What Does Being Controlling Look Like?
Now, let’s talk about control. Control is about managing someone else’s behavior, thoughts, or feelings to make you feel better. When you’re being controlling, you’re not drawing a line to protect yourself—you’re trying to force someone into doing things your way. And here’s the kicker: you may even have the best of intentions. You may think, “I just want to help them avoid mistakes,” or “I’m doing this because I love them.”
But love doesn’t manipulate, and it doesn’t control.
Controlling behavior is about trying to make other people do what you want. It might be obviously controlling, like trying to stop a new boyfriend or girlfriend from hanging out with their friends. It might be more subtle or “acceptable,” like a parent deciding what subjects their kid will take in high school without even asking them what they want.
Here’s another example. Let’s say you’re in a relationship, and your partner wants to hang out with their ex. If you say, “You can’t hang out with your ex anymore. I don’t trust you around them,” that’s controlling. You’re trying to dictate their behavior because it makes you uncomfortable.
A boundary, on the other hand, sounds like this: “I’m not comfortable being in a relationship with someone who spends time with their ex every weekend.” See the difference? You’re not forcing them to change—you’re saying what you are willing to be part of.
Sometimes control and boundaries can look similar on the surface, but the motivation behind them is completely different.
- “You can’t hang out with your friend every weekend because you used to sleep together, and I don’t trust them” is controlling.
- “I’m sorry, but I won’t be in a relationship with someone who spends time with their ex every single week” is a boundary.
Why Do We Become Controlling?
We become controlling because it makes us feel safe. When the people around us act the way we want them to, it gives us the illusion of security. But here’s the truth: you can’t control anyone but yourself. Trying to manage other people will only lead to frustration, resentment, and broken relationships.
Let’s say your teenage son wants to pursue a degree in art, but you think it’s a terrible idea. Telling him, “You’re not going to waste your time on that; you’re studying engineering,” is controlling. You’re trying to direct his life path because you feel anxious about his future.
A boundary in this situation might look more like: “I’ll support your college education as long as you have a clear plan and take responsibility for your decisions.” You’re respecting his choices while still protecting your own values and financial commitment.
How to Tell the Difference
Here’s the simplest way to know if you’re setting a boundary or being controlling: Is your goal to manage yourself or to manage them?
- A boundary says, “This is what I will do.”
- Being controlling says, “This is what you have to do.”
Let’s say your partner’s spending habits are making you anxious. A boundary might sound like, “I’m going to set a budget for myself and stick to it,” or “I’m not comfortable combining finances if we don’t have a plan.” You’re deciding how you will manage your money and protect your emotional well-being.
But if you say, “You need to stop buying clothes or we’re going to have a problem,” that’s controlling. You’re telling them what they should do to fix your anxiety, instead of taking responsibility for your own feelings and decisions.
How to Set Healthy Boundaries (Without Being Controlling)
-
Take responsibility for your feelings: Own your emotions. If you’re anxious or upset, ask yourself what you need to do to protect your well-being without controlling someone else.
-
Communicate clearly: When setting a boundary, be direct and clear about what you will do. Example: “I need to leave if the conversation turns into gossip,” rather than, “You need to stop gossiping.”
-
Follow through: A boundary without follow-through is just a wish. If you say you’re going to do something, stick to it. That’s how you earn trust and respect in your relationships.
-
Let go of the outcome: Once you set a boundary, let go of trying to control how the other person responds. Their reaction is their responsibility, not yours.
In Conclusion
Boundaries are about taking ownership of your life. They’re about protecting your heart, your time, your energy. But being controlling? That’s about trying to manage other people’s choices to make yourself feel better. And the truth is, that never works. Real peace and connection come from managing yourself—not everyone around you.
So, if you find yourself crossing that line between boundaries and control, don’t beat yourself up. Take a deep breath, step back, and remember: the only person you can control is you.